Baked mac and cheese with sharp cheddar

Baked macaroni and cheese has long reigned as the quintessential comfort food. It’s the perfect dish for a family dinner or potluck picnic, and will bring a smile to any face after a long day. This recipe, featuring a simple how to make video, uses award-winning Cabot cheddar cheese and a crunchy breadcrumb topping for a richer, more satisfying flavor than you would get from a name-brand boxed package. With just a hint of zingy spice, this mouthwatering dish will have everyone in the family asking for a second helping.  Be sure to leave us a review to let us know how much your family enjoyed the meal and to share any tips for making the dish with added flair. Your feedback can help other families share in the rich goodness that this macaroni dish has to offer. For an equally delicious, low-fat mac and cheese alternative, check out our Low Fat Mac & Cheese recipe!

The added dashes of Tabasco sauce will give the baked macaroni and cheese a slight kick, which perfectly complements the rich creaminess of the melted butter and Cabot Sharp Cheddar, Cabot Extra Sharp Cheddar, Cabot 2 Year Cheddar. The crunchy, buttery breadcrumb topping is the perfect way to finish off the dish and your family will come running as soon as it’s out of the oven. This dish is easy to make and will be well worth the time when everyone raves about the meal. 

If your family loves satisfying, home-cooked comfort food, be sure to give this baked macaroni and cheese recipe a whirl! Cabot is dedicated to making the world’s best dairy products on family farms, and our high-quality cheddar cheese sets this dish apart. Once your family has wiped their plates clean, be sure to head back over and share your thoughts with us!

Show More

Ingredients

Butter or nonstick cooking spray
2¼ cups uncooked small elbow macaroni
3 cups milk
5 tablespoons Cabot Salted Butter
3 slices firm white or whole wheat bread, pulsed into crumbs in processor or blender
3 tablespoons King Arthur Unbleached All-Purpose Flour
¾ teaspoon salt
¼ teaspoon ground black pepper
⅛ teaspoon freshly grated nutmeg
Several dashes Tabasco Sauce
16 ounces Cabot Sharp Cheddar, Cabot Extra Sharp Cheddar, or Cabot 2 Year Cheddar, grated (about 4 cups), divided

Email Grocery List

Interested in creating this tasty recipe?

Get the ingredients you need at a convenient nearby location.

Where to Buy

Directions

PREHEAT oven to 375°F. Butter 9-by-13-inch or other shallow baking dish or coat with nonstick cooking spray and set aside.

STIR macaroni into large pot of boiling salted water; cook for 5 minutes after water returns to boil, or until outside is cooked but center is still firm. Immediately drain in colander and rinse under cold water; set aside.

HEAT milk to just below a simmer in a saucepan over medium-high heat or in microwave on high power for 20 second intervals.

MELT butter over medium-low heat or in microwave. Pour 2 tablespoons of this melted butter into bowl, add breadcrumbs and blend together thoroughly; set aside.

REDUCE heat to low, add flour to butter remaining in saucepan and whisk over heat for 2 minutes, being careful not to let it color. Add warmed milk in small amounts at first, whisking until smooth after each addition; continue stirring until sauce thickens and comes to simmer. Cook, stirring often, for about 3 minutes.

REMOVE from heat and whisk in salt, pepper, nutmeg, Tabasco and half (2 cups) of grated cheese. Stir in drained pasta.

SPREAD one-third of pasta mixture over bottom of prepared baking dish. Scatter one-third of remaining cheese on top. Spoon another one-third of pasta on top and add another one-third of cheese. Top with remaining pasta. Mix remaining cheese into breadcrumbs and scatter evenly over top.

BAKE uncovered for 25 to 30 minutes, or until golden on top and bubbling throughout. Let stand for 5 minutes before serving.

Get more mac and cheese makeovers today!

4.9 out of 5 stars (based on 33 reviews)

No Title

June 13, 2022

I have not even made this recipe yet. However, it sounds just like the way my southern aunt would make baked macaroni and cheese when I was a child. I somewhat remember watching her make it. But I have one question… the recipe lists three different Cabot cheddar cheeses. Do you use all three, or is it an “either / or” choice? I cannot wait to try out your recipe.

Response from Cabot Creamery

Thank you for the question. This recipe calls for a total of 16 ounces, or 4 cups shredded, sharp cheddar and this can be a single Cabot cheddar or a mix of a couple different levels of sharpness. Mac and Cheese is always a great way to use up chunks of whatever cheese you have on hand and to try different flavors or cheddar sharpness profiles. We hope you enjoy this dish!

No Title

June 6, 2022

This is great I made it and I just loved it, it tastes amazing.

Cydney Jones

No Title

June 6, 2022

Haven’t tried THIS recipe yet but LOVE all Cabot products ESPECIALLY Seriously Sharp Cheddar. Love that the shredded cheeses also come in traditional larger shreds and family size bags at a reasonable price. GREAT PRODUCTS. Will try this Mac ‘n Cheese recipe this weekend!

Victoria McIntire

No Title

May 12, 2022

Haven’t made this yet, but ALWAYS use Cabot cheese. Love the idea of both cheesy sauce and additional cheese layers. So glad that I found this recipe.

Judy Li

No Title

October 8, 2021

So yummyyyyy 😋

yyyyyyyyy

No Title

April 6, 2021

No need to use any other recipe. This is a classic. Perfectly delicious every time!

Donna M

No Title

March 29, 2021

This is the way I make mac and cheese. CABOT cheese is a must. Sometimes I use a combination of two varieties of cheddar and a smaller portion of pepper jack. Either way, it’s the best mac and cheese ever!

Bernadette Cason

Margaret 1987 Washington County Dairy Princess

January 3, 2020

Beyond my expectations and this is the BEST

Margaret 1987 Washington County Dairy Princess

(blank)

November 1, 2019

A big hit. Any advice for making in advance and freezing?
**You can either freeze this dish before cooking, or freeze leftovers and reheat in the oven or microwave.

(blank)

Jelene

April 18, 2019

This is by far the BEST mac & cheese I have ever had an a hit with my family!! Sometimes I add a bit of pepper Jack cheese an that's also awesome.

Jelene

(blank)

January 7, 2019

Really good. Definitely will do again but without the bread crumbs since my husband did not care for the crunch.

(blank)

(blank)

November 13, 2018

Love it!

(blank)

G-Ma

October 29, 2018

Delicious ! I'm always asked for the recipe. Although our family doesn't like nutmeg, so I leave it out, you can't beat this recipe !

G-Ma

Jackie

June 19, 2018

Best mac and cheese recipe!!

Jackie

Moonbat

February 16, 2018

This is great! Will it double well or should I make two separate batches??
*Yes, doubling this recipe will work.

Moonbat

Asiya Umer

February 17, 2017

I get requests to make this all the time from both family and friends. Who wants the toxic artificial stuff from a box when you can get real comfort food like this.

Asiya Umer

Ann

February 12, 2017

My 12 year old daughter made this macaroni and cheese and it is amazing. The best I have ever had. She used crackers instead of bread crumbs.

Ann

(blank)

February 6, 2016

good

(blank)

b

February 6, 2016

yass

b

(blank)

January 22, 2016

just made this for the first time and it was a big hit! my 8 year old said it’s the best he’s ever had (and he’s had a lot!!!) thank you!

(blank)

S

October 5, 2015

Left out the nutmeg and Tabasco. It’s amazing by itself. Super easy minus grating all the cheese. I actually put this on thick sliced toasted bread and it was awesome.

S

Karen

October 3, 2015

Made this for the family! LOVE IT!

Karen

Joe

February 7, 2015

Awesome recipe creamiest mac n cheese we every made!

Joe

Peg

February 1, 2015

Made this wonderful Mac & Cheese this afternoon for an early dinner. It smelled so good I had to try it, well I wanted to eat the entire 13×9 dish full right then and there. Well, I didn't and my husband was glad I didn't. He loved it too and wanted to eat it all :-). I will always use this recipe when I make Mac & Cheese. Cabot cheese is the BEST !!!!!!!!!!!!

Peg

Kate

June 7, 2014

SUPER YUMMY and worth the effort. I made a half-batch and used the Cabot Special Reserve Super-aged cheddar – SO GOOD!

Kate

Lynne W

March 11, 2014

A bit of prep work involved but worth it–my son helped make it and just asked to have it again a 2nd time. We added real bacon bits, chopped onion and green pepper skipped nutmeg and added some red pepper flakes too. Delish dish

Lynne W

Joey

December 28, 2013

Best mac & cheese I’ve ever had! Obviously not healthy in any way, but it’s always a hit at parties and pot lucks.

Joey

Danielle

December 8, 2013

Best Recipe EVER!

Danielle

Barb

September 11, 2013

I use sliced fresh tomatoes on top

Barb

Alison

February 9, 2013

Fabulous Mac

Alison

Carol

December 31, 2012

Great Mac

Carol

Audrey

November 9, 2012

my step kids loved this- huge hit.

Audrey

Chelsea

December 1, 2011

Delicious!!!!!

Chelsea

Write a Review

Is Sharp cheddar good for mac and cheese?

With a fairly low melting point, cheddar keeps things smooth. It's also got the classic taste you're looking for and expecting with mac and cheese. Sharp cheddar is ideal because its flavor is strongest, but the most important to thing to remember is to always buy cheddar in a block and grate your own!

What type of cheese is good for baked mac and cheese?

Gruyere is a classic addition because it melts much like Cheddar, but has a lovely nutty flavor. Other classics include Gouda, Muenster, Parmesan, fontina, Havarti and Monterey Jack. Brie works well too, just make sure you remove the rind before mixing it in.

What kind of cheddar is best for mac and cheese?

Best Cheeses to Use in Mac and Cheese.
Sharp: Use sharp cheddar cheese for a stronger taste. ... .
Mild: Mild cheddar has been aged for a short time, giving it subtle flavors and a smooth melting texture..
Medium: Medium cheddar is the ideal compromise between sharp and mild varieties..

Do you use sharp or mild cheddar for mac and cheese?

There is no better choice than mild cheddar when you're making classic stovetop mac and cheese. Start with a block and grate it yourself, or opt for a convenient bag of shredded cheese.